Goldilocks or Sapphirelocks? The ‘just right’ flower colour for solitary bees


Spring has definitely sprung in the small patch of remnant native vegetation behind our house. The tiny scrap of remaining woodland jammed between McMansions, the freeway and an industrial block is glowing with golden wattle, mauve chocolate lilies and tiny scarlet & yellow peas. Last week, my eye caught an odd blaze of purple amongst the russet, green and gold – an exotic garden escapee swaying quietly in the breeze.

P1010385

It was late afternoon when I found it, and the normally star-shaped flowers had closed into cosy bells. I noticed a commotion around some of the flowers and discovered they were crammed with little clusters of solitary bees, seeking shelter for the night.

P1010285P1010371

I checked a week later, again in the late afternoon, and the bees were still there. But at midday the next day, the hot pink flowers were open flat, in their characteristic daytime star, and the bees were gone – busy foraging on native peas, golden everlastings and my kale plants.

P1010377

Evolutionary relationships between insect and flower colour traits have long intrigued pollination ecologists. Insects see the world quite differently to humans. Honey bees are generally thought to go for UV blue colours, flies tend to prefer white or yellow, while wasps and beetles often go for red. Numerous studies have tried to pinpoint the best trap colour for catching pollinators, although it’s clear that ecological context also plays a role in what colours pollinators go for under different conditions. But, in general, blue and yellow colours are generally touted as ‘the’ pollinator colours, and there are plenty of theories on why.

Most insects are pretty sensitive to cold. That’s why we rarely see solitary bees and wasps flying around in winter. But it’s not just the weather outside that affects pollinators. Some of them don’t like drinking cold nectar either, which is why most pollinators (outside tropical regions) start foraging after the sun rises and flowers have warmed a little. Different nectar concentrations warm at different rates, and different insects have different tolerance thresholds, which makes for some interesting plant-pollinator interactions.

So how does colour fit in? If you wore a black shirt on a hot summer’s day, you would be sweating buckets more than your friend wearing a white top. Similarly, darker-coloured flowers will absorb more heat, and thus be hotter during the day, than lighter-coloured flowers.

The common belief that bees prefer blue/purple flowers comes with a couple of caveats. Firstly, most of the studies or observations for this are based on honey bees or bumble bees from the northern hemisphere. Secondly, a lot of these studies have been lab-based preference experiments, so contextual ecological influences may not have been picked up. In contrast, many field-based trap colour studies have found higher pollinator catches in white or yellow traps, and you just have to look out your window to see how many pollinators are buzzing around your yellow and white flowers.

Of course, some species have shown a preference for purple flowers in various contexts. Here in Australia, the blue-banded bee (Amegilla spp.) is a favourite with native bee aficionados. I saw my first one a couple of years ago in my backyard. It flew into my garden, made straight for a purple-flowered Hebe shrub, and then disappeared over the fence again. It was about 10.30 am when I saw it, and it returned every day for the next week or so around the same time and did the same thing. I had plenty of other white and yellow flowers in the garden, but it was only interested in the Hebe. A local bee naturalist told me a similar story of a blue-banded bee’s morning visits to purple flowers in her friend’s garden. Perhaps morning is the best time to visit blue/purple flowers, before they have become too hot to handle?

P1040667

Bees and other pollinators associate warmth with floral colour, and this determines their choice to visit a particular flower at a given time. However, much of the research and discussion over this has considered these interactions from a foraging perspective – which colour flowers do bees prefer to feed on. But what about sheltering?

I’ve been checking the purple flowers in my backyard for over a week now. During the day, the flowers are open for business, but the bees aren’t interested. At night, there’s not enough room inside the corollae for them all. Similar observations were found in dark- and light-coloured irises in the Mediterranean. The darker irises were not visited at all during the day and were exclusively pollinated by the male solitary bees that used them for shelter over night…and because they warmed up quicker than lighter flowers in the morning, they offered a warm nectar reward first thing in the morning to keep the bees coming back at night.

Darker flowers absorb more heat so they will be hotter during the day – but they will also be warmer at night than pale flowers. Perhaps this is the Goldilocks context for solitary bees in temperate regions. Dark flowers may be too hot to feed on during the day, but just right at night to shelter in, while light-coloured flowers may be too cold to shelter in at night, but just right to feed on during the day. Even more excuse to keep a multicoloured garden!

P1040097

© Manu Saunders 2014

8 thoughts on “Goldilocks or Sapphirelocks? The ‘just right’ flower colour for solitary bees

  1. Emily Scott October 11, 2014 / 4:58 PM

    That photo of the solitary bees in the flower is just adorable! You must have been really pleased to get that.

    As well as the heat factor affecting which flowers bees choose, some flowers will produce nectar at certain times of day. So for example Apple flowers tend to produce more nectar in the afternoon. It could be that your Hebe is a morning nectar flower.

    Like

    • manuelinor October 11, 2014 / 5:42 PM

      They’re so cute aren’t they?! Yes, not sure whether Hebe produces more nectar in the morning, but it could be – actually I wonder if purple flowers produce more in the morning overall? There’s also the male/female thing – I think I’ve read that male flowers of some plants produce more nectar than female flowers, or vice versa. So many nuances in Nature!! Pollination in particular is such a wonderfully complex interaction!

      Like

  2. onebendintheriver October 26, 2014 / 10:42 AM

    I’ve been looking out for native bees in my garden, but they move so fast and are so little it’s hard to catch them at it. I’m impressed you did.

    Like

    • manuelinor October 26, 2014 / 4:24 PM

      Yes, they can be hard to find. It was by utter chance that I found these…and I had been looking for roosting spots for a couple of weeks!

      Like

  3. Grace November 10, 2014 / 10:48 PM

    That’s really cool. I get both the bee species you’ve mentioned in this post in my garden at home. The smaller solitary bees definitely like purple – I’ve been seeing them on Hovea, purple Dutch Iris, and Sage flowers, but not on anything else. The blue-banded bees haven’t appeared yet this year but when they’ve been around they’ve been feeding exclusively on blue Salvias – ours are just starting and haven’t seemed attractive to any pollinators yet except for European Honeybees which aren’t particularly picky. It wasn’t until I read your post and thought about it that I picked that up, so thank you.
    I’ve been photographing all the arthropods I can find in the garden to put together a reference (beneficial insects and how to attract them vs harmful insects and how to keep them in check – hopefully by encouraging beneficial insects) but I hadn’t yet picked up on the association of flower color vs bee species. Very interesting!
    Now to work out where the solitary bees are roosting in or near my garden…

    Like

    • manuelinor November 11, 2014 / 6:42 AM

      Thanks Grace! Once you start looking, it’s really exciting trying to work out the patterns. Flower colour is important, but nectar plays a role too, as Emily mentioned above – not just time of day, but some plants also peak nectar production a few days after the first flowers open.
      Your reference project sounds great – good luck with it & I hope you find some roosting bees! They’re pretty good at hiding 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s